Four Years After Oil Spill, Oak Glen Nature Preserve Shows Signs Of Healing

Mar 16, 2018

It's been four years since an oil pipeline in Colerain Township ruptured, spewing thousands of gallons of crude down a hillside creek at Oak Glen Nature Preserve. In 2016, the focus shifted from cleaning the site, to restoration. That process is nearing completion.

The view, however, remains vastly different than it was before the Mid-Valley Pipeline burst on March 17, 2014.

"There's been a big change here because this used to be a containment dam that was built to contain oil that came from the pipeline spill in 2014," says Bret Henninger, chief of conservation and parks with Great Parks of Hamilton County.

A containment dam built just after the spill in 2014 to keep more oil from flowing into the pond at the bottom of the hill. The images show the dam in 2014 (left) and 2016 (right).
Credit Tana Weingartner / WVXU

Henninger is gazing down on a gully with a stream that gives way to a swampy pond. The creek bed is man-made, and it looks it. Large slabs of stone make it feel like a child's nature playscape. Dirt covers the banks rather than forest.

But still, it's progress.

"The site's starting to heal now," he says. "There's no (bull)dozers. There's no equipment in sight... It's nice to see the nature preserve begin to start to heal."

During cleanup, crews used industrial hoses and rakes to unearth oil and push it downstream where it was collected and hauled away. That process caused massive erosion, widening the stream and destroying habitat.

RELATED: Read more about the cleanup process.

Restoration began about a year and a half ago. Before that, contractors for Sunoco Logistics removed roughly 19,000 gallons of oil. The company estimates 20,000 spilled from the broken pipeline. Well more than initial estimates of 7,000-10,000 gallons in 2014.

Environment officials in 2014 worried oil would spill over from this pond, pictured in April 2014 and March 2018, into the Great Miami River not far from the preserve's boarder.
Credit Tana Weingartner/WVXU / Ohio EPA

It settled with the park district in 2016, agreeing to fund the cleanup, and pay out $923,000.

Spokesman Jeff Shields tells WVXU the company has "worked diligently with the Great Parks of Hamilton County and the Ohio EPA over the past four years that the Oak Glen Nature Preserve is properly restored to the satisfaction of all landowners.

"This was a cooperative effort involving multiple parties, and today the major restoration is done. We will be monitoring the site for the next 10 years and making any repairs and/or modifications as necessary."

Oil remains at the site. Removing every last drop would've meant tearing out the forest, doing more damage than the spill itself.

The goal now is to get the preserve back to a semblance of what it was. Hundreds of saplings replace gravel roads constructed during cleanup. Herbicides are weeding out invasive plants tracked in by workers that are overwhelming native species. Scientists monitor the creek for signs of life like insects and cave salamanders - an endangered species in Ohio and a key environmental indicator. You won't find them if the water quality is poor. Great Parks is also waiting to see if the rare lark sparrow will return to the preserve's prairie.

Scientists are monitoring the stream for the return of insects like this sow bug. What they'd really like to find are cave salamanders which would indicate good water quality.
Credit Tana Weingartner / WVXU

Great Parks Director of Marketing and Public Engagement Jennifer Sivak remembers vividly the awful moment when she first heard about the spill. Gazing across the preserve four years later, she's conflicted.

"Right now, I think it looks like a different preserve than what it was, but as you come up the stream and go up even closer to the break, it starts to feel like the nature preserve that we know and love."
 

The cleanup left the stream much wider and straighter than before. High-powered hoses and repeated brushing and raking led to bank erosion. Saplings in the foreground replace older trees removed because of contamination or in order to reach the cleanup zones.
Credit Tana Weingartner / WVXU

Bret Henniger says protecting places like Oak Glen is important because it's a part of Ohio's history. These natural resources, he says, defined the region for hundreds of years.

"I think it's preserving an extraordinary place. We want people to be able to visit places where they can imagine themselves in that place 2-300 years ago and this is one of those places where when you get deep into the woods up on the hill you forget you're in a metropolitan area, a county of 800,000 people. It's a pretty neat place."

Oak Glen remains closed to the public. Restoration should wrap up this summer. After that, the preserve will re-open once U.S. Fish and Wildlife, the Ohio EPA and Great Parks are convinced the plants and wildlife are stable and humans won't affect their return.